Everything music & ear training related

ToneGym

profile
Primat Duha
Sep 07
Is it really possible for a human to hear inversions of the chords? 🥲
profile
Dima G
Sep 07
it's very hard and imo super low on the list of priorities for what you'd use when playing music in real life. it's much more important to identify the chord progression + then be able to identify the inversion based on the bass note. the key word is in context. identifying random inversions in isolation doesn't help that much in my opinion.
profile
But still, chords in second inversion sound so mysterious and irresolute as compared to the root position... it has this Chopin feel to it.

I wouldn't exclude them from my list, and yes, they sound totally different and you will hear it. But as @Dima G was saying, put it lower in your list of priorities.
profile
Terri Winters
Sep 07
Definitely @Dima G said - hearing the bass note really helps with this exercise.
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Sep 07
It depends on the human
profile
Benjamin Jack
Sep 07
I am still not sure. I think so, but there are days that I am pulling my hair out over them. I can generally recognize a root because to me, at least, it feels less wide than a 1 or 2. But I am still often hit or miss over 1 vs 2.

Dima G is right--they should be low on your priority list.
profile
I'm still struggling with this one
Hope that progress will come with exercice😊
profile
Colin Aiken
Sep 08
@Cuantas Vacas is an inversion.
profile
Ti Filimona
Sep 08
I'm afraid so.....especially Jazz musicians
profile
yes, try listening to each individual note that makes up the chord and their interval distance. for example a major chord in root position is M3, m3 together you can hear a p5 between the low and highest note. then if you go to the 1st inversion it goes m3,p4 and then you'll hear a m6 between the lowest and highest note. I started writing down these in my own little cheat sheet and now can hear the inversions after a while.
profile
Cuantas Vacas
Sep 08
And @Colin Aiken can hear me...
profile
Colin Aiken
Sep 09
Just barely, my old ears don't work as good as they used to.
profile
Primat Duha
Sep 11